Mis-representing “gay on gay” murders as “homophobic” killings an international commitment ?

Do  LGBT  activists  persistently  and deliberately   manipulate  the truth  about  some murders  of  members  of  their  community – labeling  them   “homophobic”  killings  ( done  by  straight  persons  because  the  victim  was  homosexual) when  they  are  in fact   crimes  of  passion  etc  and  the  murderer  another  member  of   the homosexual   community?

Testifyingtotruth”   rejects  the  innuendo  of  mental  illness  in those  who  do  not  agree  with   the homosexual  lifestyle  by  the labeling  “homophobic”  but   is  not  suggesting  that  homosexuals  in Jamaica  are  never  subjected  to  violence  or  may  be  killed  because  they  are  homosexuals .  

This  blog  however  questions  the  validity  of  some  of  the claims  of   “homophobic”  killings   

It  is  to  be  noted  that   Police  Officer  Les Green  has   suggested  that  the  extravagant  claims  of  gay  activists  and  their supporters  in  labeling  killings  as  homophobic  is  unsubstantiated.  


Gay lobby claims not true, says Green

‘Jamaica far more tolerant of homosexuals than the public hype’

BY KARYL WALKER Online news editor walkerk@jamaicaobserver.com

Sunday, July 08, 2012

A day before former Assistant Commissioner of Police Les Green left the island at the end of his eight years of service, he rubbished a common claim by the gay community and international rights groups that homosexuals in Jamaica are victims of wanton murder, mob-mauling and marginalisation.

His pronouncement came just weeks after gay lobby group Jamaica Forum For Lesbians All-sexuals and Gays (JFLAG) suggested that two men killed in the New Kingston area were slain because of their sexual preference.



Two cross-dressers pose for photos at a Fashion Week event in Kingston last month where they moved around without being harassed.

GREEN… all of those murders that I have investigated have been in relationships and are victims of gay attacks, domestic situations (Photo: Michael Gordon)

This gay man tries to hide his face as he and other homosexuals are escorted by police from a pharmacy in St Andrew after their actions drew a large crowd in February 2007. (Photo: Observer library)

In an interview on Thursday with the Sunday Observer, Green said despite claims by JFLAG that Jamaicans are intolerant of their lifestyle, and are targeting them for death, his experience during his tenure here was totally different.

Read more: http://www.jamaicaobserver.com/news/Gay-lobby-claims-not-true–says-Green#ixzz2BDTfkTqu


David  Kato’s murder  in Uganda

The commitment  to  misrepresent  “gay  on gay”  violence  as  “homophobic”  killings   occurs  at  the  highest levels   of  politics  and  academia.

In the article  below published  in the special  issue  of  the  Lancet  for  the  XIX International  conference  on HIV/AIDS  in Washington DC   the authors  appear  to  be  suggesting  that  David  Kato’s  murder  was  a  “homophobic”  killing. 

Kato  was   a  Ugandan Gay-rights  activist.   

HIV in men who have sex with men 5

Common roots: a contextual review of HIV epidemics in black men who have sex with men across the African diaspora

Gregorio A Millett, William L Jeff ries “th, John L Peterson, David J Malebranche, Tim Lane, Stephen A Flores, Kevin A Fenton, Patrick A Wilson,
Riley Steiner, Charles M Heilig

Same-sex behaviour is criminalised in 38 African and  10 Caribbean countries.70 In some countries, homosexuality is punishable by lengthy prison terms or death.
Well publicised examples of state-sanctioned homophobia include the arrest and conviction in 2010 of two  Malawian men who married one another,80 several
accounts of intimidation of and violence against gay men in Jamaica,55 the 2011 murder of Ugandan gay-rights  activist David Kato,81 and threats by the Gambian
President Yahya Jammeh to decapitate homosexuals.82 Law enforcement officials in Africa and the Caribbean  routinely ignore or participate in anti-gay violence, 55,83
and local media publish photographs, names, and addresses of homosexual men, making them targets for  abuse.74,84 Additionally, in Uganda and Nigeria the lives of  people providing health-care services are jeopardised if  they do not report people who have disclosed same-sex behaviour.85,8

Ugandan  Newspaper  the   Daily  Monitor posted  the  following  on the court  case.


Gay activist murderer sentenced to 30 years

Sidney Nsubuga Enoch (L) the man suspected to have murdered Ugandan gay rights activist David Kato has been sentenced to 30 years imprisonment for the crime. Photo by Johnson Mayamba

Posted  Thursday, November 10  2011 at  10:38

Mukono High Court has on Thursday sentenced Sidney Nsubuga Enoch, 22, the man suspected to have murdered a gay rights activist in January this year, to 30 years in prison.

The 30 year sentence was passed by Justice Joseph Mulangira after Nsubuga admitted to have murdered David Kato 46, on 26th January 2011. This verdict was passed based on the evidence produced in court by the lead state prosecutor, Ms. Loe Karungi.

Prosecution led by Ms Karungi alleges that on 26th January, 2011, at around 8:30am, while the duo was taking tea, the deceased demanded for sex from Nsubuga. “The deceased started kissing Nsubuga and tickling him but in the process, a one Kizza Akram knocked at the door and the deceased stopped what he was doing,” Ms. Karungi told court.

After breakfast, Kizza went away to the farm where the accused followed. They both uprooted cassava and Nsubuga came back leaving Kizza in the garden. “Nsubuga prepared lunch for Kizza and the deceased. After lunch the deceased locked the house and informed Nsubuga that it was time for sex,” Ms. Karungi said.

This is the time Nsubuga told the deceased that he wanted to ease himself in the bathroom after which he would come back and have sex. “While in the bathroom, Nsubuga picked up a hammer, came back to the living room and hit the deceased on the back of the head twice,” Ms.Karungi narrated.

Ms Karungi says that Nsubuga then dragged the deceased to the bedroom where he started picking items from the deceased’s bag. The items picked included a camera, keyboard for a computer, T.shirts, shoes and a mobile phone. He opened the door, got out, and locked the door from outside. He then threw the keys in the gumboots that were outside.

It is also said that at 2:00 PM on that fateful day, Kizza came back from the farm and found the door locked and the music was playing loud from the house. After waiting for a while, Kizza inquired from the neighbors where Kato was and they told him that they did not know. They however informed Kizza that they had seen Nsubuga leaving the house dressed in the deceased’s clothes.

This prompted Kizza and the neighbors to peep in the deceased’s house where they saw fresh blood stains on the living room floor that prompted them to search for the house keys. Upon entering the house, they saw blood stains leading to the bedroom, where the deceased was discovered lying unconscious on the bed in a pool blood.

“They rushed him to Kyetume Health Center, from where they were referred to Mulago Hospital but the deceased passed away before this could happen. David Kato’s body was then takento Kawolo Hospital for postmortem where they discovered that the deceased had been seriously hit at the back of the head,” Ms Karungi noted.

The hunt for Nsubuga culminated in his arrest when he was spotted by Nakabago residents in Mukono district, who alerted the police. He was arrested and taken to Mukono Police Station where he admitted to the murder charges brought against him. Ms. Karungi then told court that the case against the Nsubuga was very serious and she asked court for a maximum penalty basing on the evidence that had been presented and that basing on the fact that the accused had admitted to the crime.

Efforts to reach leaders of gay community, Sexual Minorities Uganda (SMUG) were futile as they are said to be out of the country to receive an award at Rafto Prize Ceremony at Den Nationale Scene recognizing them for their struggle in the fight for gay rights in Uganda.

Kato’s death was condemned by both local and international human rights bodies including United States President Barack Obama, saying it was an abuse of fundamental human rights.

They called upon the government to investigate the cause of his death and speak out against homophobia towards the gay community in the country. The police issued a statement to the effect that Kato’s killing was no way related to his campaign for gay rights.

This entry was posted in David Kato, Gay activists, Gay on Gay violence, Homophobia, homophobic killing. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Mis-representing “gay on gay” murders as “homophobic” killings an international commitment ?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s